
Staffing isn’t as easy as it looks. This perspective draws on Tidewater Staffing management’s experience building and operating a family-owned staffing business for more than three decades.
From the outside, staffing can look like a relatively simple business. A company needs a welder, fitter, electrician, firewatch, or another qualified employee. A staffing company finds that person, pays them one rate, bills the customer another rate, and keeps the difference.
When you look at an invoice, the math can seem pretty compelling.
But Tidewater Staffing’s experience over more than three decades shows that quite a bit happens between those two numbers.
That doesn’t mean staffing is a bad business. Far from it. It has supported a family-owned company and allowed Tidewater Staffing to put a lot of people to work over the years.
Staffing isn’t as easy as it looks, and understanding the responsibilities behind each placement helps explain why.
Markup Isn’t Profit
One of the easiest misconceptions to make is looking at the difference between an employee’s wage and the customer’s bill rate and assuming that difference is profit.
It isn’t.
Before the staffing company makes anything, that spread has to cover payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, unemployment, insurance, recruiting, background checks, drug screens, safety, payroll administration, HR, benefits, bad debt, financing costs, and the staff required to keep the whole thing moving.
In an industrial environment, those costs and risks become even more significant.
A staffing company isn’t simply buying labor for one price and selling it for another. It is taking responsibility for employing that individual and everything that comes with it.
There is a big difference.
You Have to Pay Friday
Cash flow is another part of the business that isn’t particularly obvious from the outside.
Employees expect their paycheck every week. Customers don’t necessarily pay every week.
A staffing company may pay several weeks of payroll, payroll taxes, insurance, and operating expenses before receiving payment from the customer.
As a staffing company grows, that working-capital requirement grows right along with it.
In fact, growth can create as many problems as it solves.
Adding 50 employees may be wonderful for revenue, but it also means funding 50 additional paychecks every week while waiting for the corresponding invoices to be paid.
A profitable staffing company can still find itself short of cash.
Managing that gap is one of the fundamental parts of the business.
Recruiting Is a Production Process
Another common assumption is that knowing a lot of people in an industry means you can recruit them.
That certainly helps.
But knowing 20 good welders isn’t the same thing as maintaining a workforce capable of supporting dozens of customers and hundreds—or thousands—of placements.
People quit. Projects end. Employees move. Some don’t pass qualification tests. Some don’t show up. Some find permanent positions. Customers suddenly need 20 additional people on Monday morning.
The recruiting process never really stops.
Staffing companies have to continually rebuild their pool of available talent. That work involves people, each with their own skills, circumstances, and goals.
That makes this business fundamentally different from selling a product that can be manufactured, put on a shelf, and sold when the customer needs it.
When Tidewater Staffing successfully places a good employee, that employee is no longer available for the next customer.
So the search continues.
The Easy Customer Can Create a Hard Problem
Tidewater Staffing’s management has also observed another dynamic when operating companies decide to create their own staffing firms.
It usually begins logically.
A contractor is already spending a substantial amount of money with staffing companies. Management looks at those invoices and thinks, “Why don’t we create our own staffing company and capture some of that margin?”
For their own workforce, that may make sense.
The problem comes when the new company tries to sell staffing services to everybody else.
Suppose a ship repair contractor creates a staffing company.
Another ship repair contractor now has to ask itself a few uncomfortable questions.
If there are ten great welders available, who gets them first?
The outside customer—or the company that owns the staffing firm?
What happens to information about an upcoming project, a labor shortage, wage rates, staffing levels, schedules, or future manpower requirements?
Could employees supplied to one contractor ultimately be recruited for the owner’s operation?
None of those questions mean the staffing company intends to do anything improper.
The problem is that the questions exist at all.
Staffing relationships require a considerable amount of trust.
Customers routinely give staffing companies insight into their operations that they may not want to share with a competitor.
That is why independence matters.
A staffing company that doesn’t compete with its customers can simply focus on helping those customers succeed.
At Tidewater Staffing, the customers’ work remains their work. The company’s role is to help them put the workforce in place to execute their ship repair contracts, fabrication projects, or construction jobs—not to pursue those projects itself.
That distinction is more important than it may initially appear.
Why Staffing Isn’t as Easy as It Looks
Then there is everything customers rarely see.
A Monday morning in staffing can involve employees calling out, payroll questions, workers’ compensation claims, customer requests, background checks, drug screens, timesheet problems, unemployment claims, onboarding, safety issues, collections, and a customer who suddenly needs five people tomorrow.
Meanwhile, recruiting continues.
Sales continue.
Payroll continues.
And Friday is still coming.
None of this is intended to make staffing sound unnecessarily complicated. Like most businesses, it becomes manageable when the proper systems, people, capital, and experience are in place.
But those things take time to build.
That is probably the most important distinction.
The barrier to starting a staffing company is relatively low.
The barrier to building a good staffing company is considerably higher.
There are systems to develop, relationships to earn, mistakes to make, lessons to learn, and enough working capital required to survive all of them.
After more than 30 years, Tidewater Staffing continues to learn something new about this business.
That experience shapes management’s view of staffing as more than simply supplying people.
It is about building infrastructure between people who want to work and companies that need work done.
When that infrastructure works well, it can look remarkably simple.
Usually, that’s a sign that there is a lot happening behind the scenes.